How free are insurers to provide the insurance products consumers want?
That’s a key question that the R Street Institute’s Insurance Regulation Report Card seeks to answer.
And it’s a very good question.
In the fourth and latest edition of the report R Street observes that regulation, in some cases, may hinder the speed with which new products are brought to market:
R Street says the most recent illustration of this challenge is seen in the different approaches individual states have taken to enable the timely introduction of commercial and personal insurance policies to cover ridesharing.
A compromise model bill to govern insurance requirements for ridesharing was announced by major representatives of the insurance industry and the burgeoning transportation network companies in March 2015.
The legislation alleviated what had been a major source of interindustry friction, R Street notes.
The model requires that:
— liability insurance with limits of $1 million be in-force any time a driver either is actively transporting a customer or en route to pick up a fare.
— any other time the driver is logged in to the TNC service, he or she must have coverage with minimum liability limits of $50,000 per passenger, $100,000 per incident and $25,000 for physical damage liability.
R Street writes:
The model would permit coverage to be procured either by the driver or the TNC, expressly stipulates that it may be provided by the surplus lines market, preserves insurers’ right to exclude coverage and encourages states to approve new products to cover this emerging risk.”
Signatories to the compromise include Allstate, the American Insurance Association, Farmers Insurance, Lyft, the National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies, the Property Casualty Insurers Association of America, State Farm, Uber Technologies and USAA.
The report notes that in April 2015, Georgia became the first state to pass the compromise model ridesharing bill. The measure, H.B. 190, took effect January 1, 2016.
Have more questions? Check out the Insurance Information Institute’s (I.I.I.) Q&A on Ridesharing and Insurance.
An I.I.I. issues update on regulation modernization is available here.